Conri Botha
Director

Insight
January 14, 2025

Securing a property sale is no small feat for Property Practitioners. From tirelessly networking and arranging countless viewings to handling tough negotiations and managing client expectations, every successful deal is the result of dedication, persistence, and skill. Yet, despite these efforts, disputes over commission can still arise, casting a shadow over a Property Practitioner’s hard-earned success. A recent case in the Western Cape High Court, City and Atlantic Real Estate CC t/a RE/MAX Living v. Smith and Others, offers valuable lessons for Property Practitioners on how to protect their rights and avoid similar challenges.
The case centred on two property agencies, RE/MAX Living and Kapstadt International Properties, both of whom claimed entitlement to commission on the sale of a high-value property. The dispute involved the legal principle of “effective cause,” which determines which Practitioner’s efforts led directly to the sale.
RE/MAX Living had introduced the buyer, Mr James Pears, to the property during the validity of their joint mandate with Kapstadt. They facilitated multiple viewings, engaged in negotiations, and remained in contact with the buyer throughout the mandate period. However, the buyer ultimately concluded the transaction through Kapstadt almost a year later. The sellers, aware of RE/MAX Living’s initial involvement, had indemnified themselves against potential claims from both agencies. This created a complex situation, requiring the court to determine which agency’s actions were the primary and effective cause of the sale.
The court ruled in favour of RE/MAX Living, finding that their efforts during the mandate period were the causa causans — the dominant and effective cause — of the sale. The judgment highlighted several key principles Property Practitioners should keep in mind:
This case underscores the importance of aligning operational practices with legal frameworks. Property Practitioners, who often rely on commission as their primary income source, cannot afford to overlook the finer points of their legal arrangements.
By ensuring that mandates are clear, actions are well-documented, and potential conflicts are anticipated, Practitioners can safeguard their interests and focus on what they do best: connecting buyers with their dream properties.
By Conri Botha | Director