Eloise Cilliers
Senior Associate - Corporate Disputes

Insight
June 11, 2025

Experience shows that the moment disciplinary action looms, some employees abandon the real dispute and head straight for their keyboards, hoping a social-media storm will drown out the facts. That strategy backfired spectacularly for two former Liberty Group staff members, whose digital tirades have now been branded defamatory by the High Court. The case of Liberty Group v Chonco and Another is a timely warning: freedom of expression ends where unsubstantiated allegations begin.
After parting ways with Liberty, branch manager Siyabonga Chonco and contracted financial adviser Siyakutanda Mafuna took to Facebook, X (Twitter), LinkedIn and WhatsApp with a barrage of claims: corruption, sexism, abuse—even calling Liberty a “scam” and “trash”. They dragged Standard Bank (a Liberty shareholder) into the fray and singled out executives as “woman abusers”.
Neither could produce evidence. What they did produce was plenty of reputational risk—for themselves.
Judge Mathenjwa had little patience for rhetoric unsupported by facts. To defend a defamatory statement, one must either prove its truth and public-interest value or show it is fair comment anchored in accurate information.
Contradictions in the respondents’ own narratives (for example, admitting Mafuna was exonerated at a disciplinary hearing yet still crying foul) further eroded credibility.
The judgment underlines a simple principle: if you believe you were wronged, the CCMA or Labour Court is the proper venue - your newsfeed is not. Posting sensational accusations may feel cathartic, but it exposes you to a defamation suit and, as here, an interdict requiring deletion of all offending content.
Opinion may be protected, but only when:
Inflammatory labels like “criminal” and “trash” failed that test.
The court granted a final interdict compelling Chonco and Mafuna to scrub every defamatory post and barred them from publishing fresh content about Liberty, its employees or Standard Bank. They must also foot Liberty’s legal bill. Continuous postings after “promising to stop” convinced the court future harm was likely.
Baseless online attacks need not go unanswered. Liberty Group v Chonco confirms that employers - and indeed any organisation - can and should defend their reputation when defamation masquerades as grievance. In the digital age, accountability travels just as fast as a tweet.