Koos Benadie
Director

Insight
October 10, 2025

South African courts carry heavy backlogs, and many civil matters take years to conclude. That pressure recently prompted the Gauteng Division of the High Court to require mediation (with a mediator’s report) before a trial date is allocated. Mediation may be getting all the headlines currently, but, arbitration remains a powerful, private alternative that can reduce court congestion, improve access to justice, and resolve disputes more quickly and confidentially.
Unlike mediation, arbitration is consensual and adjudicative. Parties agree in writing to refer disputes to an independent arbitrator who hears the matter and issues a binding decision - an arbitration award - under the Arbitration Act 42 of 1965.
Section 28 of the Act provides that an arbitration award is final and binding between the parties. There is no appeal on the merits. Court involvement is limited and supervisory. A court may remit an award back to the tribunal in narrow circumstances or set it aside for serious defects in process, not because it would have reached a different outcome.
Within six weeks of publication of the award, the parties may jointly agree in writing to remit the dispute to the tribunal for reconsideration or for a fresh/further award (section 32). If they cannot agree, either party may apply to court - on notice to the other and on good cause - for an order of remittal. Once remitted, the tribunal typically has three months to dispose of the matter from the date of remittal.
A court may set an award aside (on application, within six weeks of publication) only if:
If an award is set aside, either party may require that the dispute be submitted to a new tribunal. This is a safeguard for process integrity, not a second bite at the merits.
Arbitration gives parties a private, efficient forum and a binding result, with limited, time-bound avenues to fix serious procedural defects. Understanding the remittal and setting-aside routes and their strict timelines, helps parties protect both speed and fairness.
Need help drafting an arbitration clause, going the arbitration route instead of court, challenging an award on process, or enforcing one as a court order? Barnard’s dispute resolution team can review your position, map the correct route (remittal, review, or enforcement), and act within the relevant timeframes.